'Our murdered girls brought us together - now we're changing the law'

BBC Two women sat outside of on a sofa sitting next to each other and smiling. Carole, on the left, has blonde hair and is wearing a blue and white patterned vest. Julie, on the right, is wearing a light green dress and wearing glasses.BBC
Carole Gould (L) and Julie Devey have fought for justice for their murdered daughters

Carole Gould and Julie Devey became friends through tragic circumstances - their teenage daughters were both murdered at home by their ex-boyfriend.

Their meeting started a journey to change the law for families in the same position, with BBC West home affairs correspondent Fiona Lamdin following their now-successful campaign.

I met Carole seven years ago, six months after her 17-year-old daughter Ellie Gould was murdered.

Carole left her daughter revising for her mock exams at home in Calne, Wiltshire, as she left for work on 3 May 2019. When she got home four hours later, the house was cordoned off with police tape, with officers guarding the door.

Carole knew something was very wrong but never imagined, as she fought her way into her home, that her daughter had been stabbed to death by her ex-boyfriend Thomas Griffiths, who was 17 at the time.

A selfie of a young girl with curly brunette hair wearing a red dress with a diamante collar and red lipstick.
Ellie Gould had ended her three-month relationship with Thomas Griffiths the day before he murdered her

Ellie and Griffiths had been at school together for years. He had celebrated Ellie's 17th birthday with the Gould family just months earlier.

The day before he murdered Ellie, she had ended their three-month relationship.

That morning his mum dropped him at school, but once there he emailed teachers saying he was ill. He caught the bus home and hid in his wardrobe until his mum had gone out.

Despite being a learner driver, he took the keys to the family car and drove to Ellie's house.

He strangled her before stabbing her repeatedly in the neck with a kitchen knife, leaving her hand on the knife handle.

Unbelievably, Carole told me Ellie had completed a piece of work before her death on whether child murderers should be punished.

"She got the results for that on the Monday and on the Friday she was murdered herself," Carole said.

"To me there is some message - Mum, you had to do that to save other young girls and women - and she'd be incredibly proud we did it."

Griffiths was jailed for 12-and-a-half years for killing Ellie.

"It just didn't seem right that a person who bought a knife and murdered a stranger on the street faced a 25-year starting point, whereas someone who murdered a partner or ex-partner at home with a kitchen knife faces a 15-year starting point," Carole said. "How is that justice?"

In 2019, Carole had never been interviewed by a journalist or argued her case with a politician, but that was soon to change.

On the night Griffiths started his prison sentence, BBC Points West broadcast a 30-minute programme about Ellie's life, led by Carole.

Sat at home watching from her sofa in Frome, Somerset, was Julie.

Her 24-year-old daughter Poppy Devey Waterhouse had been murdered five months before Ellie.

Julie Devey A young girl with blonde hair who appears to be standing in a field. She is looking at the camera and smiling, wearing a white vest and sunglasses.Julie Devey
Poppy Devey Waterhouse was killed by her ex-boyfriend in 2018

Poppy had been with her boyfriend Joe Atkinson for three years. When she ended the relationship, he was consumed by jealousy and attacked her with a kitchen knife at their flat. Joe was sent to prison for a minimum term of 15 years and 310 days.

Julie said she knew "exactly" what Carole was going through, because she was living it too.

"I had to reach out and it was amazing to hear straight back," she said.

"I knew we were going to make such a strong connection."

A few months later, Carole and Julie met and formed a close friendship. They founded the group Killed Women, campaigning for changes to domestic homicide sentencing.

"Once I found Julie there was a newfound strength. We linked arms and I thought 'I can do this'," Carole said.

For the next seven years, the pair met justice ministers, politicians and judges in London to try to persuade them to change the law.

Last month, Justice Secretary David Lammy announced plans to raise the minimum starting sentence for murdering a current or former partner to 25 years - in line with other premeditated killings.

Family handout A young girl with long brown hair wearing a burgundy and white striped shirt is holding a glass of lemonade. She is sat next to her mum who is holding a glass of prosecco.Family handout
Carole said she is she feels a "weight has been lifted" by the law change announcement

"It didn't feel as if it would ever happen," said Carole.

"It has been a difficult seven years, we've met seven justice ministers, all with a sympathetic nodding.

"Until now, no justice minister has been bold enough to make the change.

"[It has been] a lot of sweat and tears but we've finally got it over the line," she continued.

'We won't ever be free'

The law change is subject to consultation with the Sentencing Council, but the Ministry of Justice said it would be introduced as soon as possible.

"Thomas Griffiths only got 12-and-a-half years for the brutal murder of Ellie," Carole said.

"With these changes, he would have got around 26 years."

Julie said Atkinson would have also got a little more than 26 years for Poppy's murder.

"It is not long left before they are free, but we won't ever be free," she said.

Three women sit side by side on a grey sofa. They all have straight blonde hair which is around their shoulders. They are smiling and each have their hands in their lap. There are two glasses of water and a bouquet of flowers on a coffee table in front of them.
BBC correspondent Fiona Lamdin (L) with Carole Gould (C) and Julie Devey in 2023

As a journalist I have followed every twist and turn of Carole and Julie's journey.

There were times it seemed impossible as they kept being knocked back, after hundreds of phone calls made, emails sent and meetings had.

There were times I feared nothing would change, but these mothers were absolutely determined, their daughters driving them on.

They always said it would be a marathon, not a sprint, and I am incredibly proud of what they have done.

  • If you or someone you know has been affected by the details raised in this story, advice on where to find help and support can be found at BBC Action Line.

Follow BBC Wiltshire on Facebook, X and Instagram. Send your story ideas to us on email or via WhatsApp on 0800 313 4630.